| Filmfare Award | Year | Actress | Film |
|---|---|---|---|
| 35th | 1991 | Awarded to a male actor | |
| 36th | 1992 | Not Awarded | |
| 37th | 1993 | Dimple Kapadia | Rudaali |
| 38th | 1994 | Awarded to a male actor | |
| 39th | 1995 | Farida Jalal | Mammo |
| 40th | 1996 | Manisha Koirala | Bombay |
| 41st | 1997 | Manisha Koirala | Khamoshi: The Musical |
| 42nd | 1998 | Tabu | Virasat |
| 43rd | 1999 | Shefali Shah | Satya |
| Filmfare Award | Year | Actress | Film |
|---|---|---|---|
| 45th | 2000 | Tabu | Hu Tu Tu |
| 46th | 2001 | Tabu | Astitva |
| 47th | 2002 | Karisma Kapoor | Zubeidaa |
| 48th | 2003 | Manisha Koirala | Company |
| Rani Mukerji | Saathiya | ||
| 49th | 2004 | Urmila Matondkar | Bhoot |
| 50th | 2005 | Kareena Kapoor | Dev |
| 51st | 2006 | Rani Mukerji | Black |
| 52nd | 2007 | Kareena Kapoor | Omkara |
| 53rd | 2008 | Tabu | Cheeni Kum |
| 54th | 2009 | Shahana Goswami | Rock On!! |
| Filmfare Award | Year | Actress | Film |
|---|---|---|---|
| 55th | 2010 | +Mahi Gill | Dev.D |
| 56th | 2011 | +Vidya Balan | Ishqiya |
| 57th | 2012 | +Priyanka Chopra | 7 Khoon Maaf |
| 58th | 2013 | +Richa Chadda | Gangs of Wasseypur |
| 59th | 2014 | +Shilpa Shukla | B.A. Pass |
| 60th | 2015 | +Alia Bhatt | Highway |
| 61st | 2016 | +Kangana Ranaut | Tanu Weds Manu Returns |
| 62nd | 2017 | +Sonam Kapoor | Neerja |
| 63rd | 2018 | +Zaira Wasim | Secret Superstar |
| Kangana Ranaut | Mom | ||
| Sridevi | Anaarkali of Aarah' | ||
| Vidya Balan | Tumhari Sulu | ||
| 64th | 2019 | +Neena Gupta | Badhaai Ho |
| Anushka Sharma | Sui Dhaaga | ||
| Alia Bhatt | Raazi | ||
| Radhika Madan | Pataakha | ||
| Taapsee Pannu | Mulk | ||
| Tabu | Andhadhun | ||
| 65th | 2020 | +Taapsee Pannu | Saand Ki Aankh |
| +Bhumi Pednekar | Saand Ki Aankh | ||
| Bhumi Pednekar | Sonchiriya | ||
| Kangana Ranaut | Judgementall Hai Kya | ||
| Radhika Madan | Mard Ko Dard Nahi Hota | ||
| Sanya Malhotra | Photograph |
| Filmfare Award | Year | Actress | Film |
|---|---|---|---|
| 65th | 2020 | +Taapsee Pannu | Saand Ki Aankh |
| +Bhumi Pednekar | Saand Ki Aankh | ||
| Bhumi Pednekar | Sonchiriya | ||
| Kangana Ranaut | Judgementall Hai Kya | ||
| Radhika Madan | Mard Ko Dard Nahi Hota | ||
| Sanya Malhotra | Photograph | ||
| 66th | 2021 | +Tillotama Shome | Sir |
| Bhumi Pednekar | Dolly Kitty Aur Woh Chamakte Sitare | ||
| Konkona Sen Sharma | |||
| Sanya Malhotra | Ludo | ||
| Taapsee Pannu | Thappad | ||
| Vidya Balan | Shakuntala Devi |